Skip to content Skip to navigation

Philosophy Department Colloquium Series: Maria Lasonen-Aarnio

October 10, 2014 - 3:15pm to 5:00pm
Building 90, room 92Q, Main Quad

All events are free and open to the public.

Enkrasia or Evidentialism? Learning to Love Mismatch

Abstract: 
In this talk I spell out a paradox, discuss various ways out, and sketch a solution. The paradox is created by combining evidentialism, enkratic or anti-akratic principles in epistemology, and the idea that evidence can be misled about what it supports. According to evidentialism, a subject is permitted to believe, or at least be confident in, a proposition p if her evidence makes p likely, or supports p. But if evidence can be misled about what it supports, then evidence can support p, while supporting the proposition that it doesn’t support p. Then, by evidentialism, a subject can be permitted to believe p, and to believe that her evidence doesn’t support p. However, many have defended the idea that subjects are never permitted to be epistemically akratic in this way. Indeed, many take enkratic principles prohibiting such states to be so self-evident as to not require further defense.
I discuss and reject various responses to the paradox. I put forth an alternative, which sees the paradox as an instance of a more general phenomenon, namely, the way in which any rule or norm seems to generate derivative rules or norms. Ultimately, I argue that the paradox should be solved by rejecting the enkratic requirements in epistemology. My account of their appeal makes use of a distinction between evaluating a state from the perspective of whether it conforms to correct epistemic norms, one the one hand, and the perspective of whether it is practically rational given the goal of conforming to the correct epistemic norms, on the other.
Professor Maria Lasonen-Aarnio is Assistant Professor of Philosophy at the University of Michigan.
The Philosophy Department Colloquia Series is an annual lecture series that features talks by invited speakers. Each colloquium typically take place every Friday afternoon at 3:15 pm during the academic year, however, there are exceptions, so please check our events webpage. All events are free and open to the public.

Event Sponsor: 
Department of Philosophy
Contact Email: 
etopete@stanford.edu
Contact Phone: 
650 723 2547